Problem Management
This chapter is a first draft. It contains some ideas that have to be
validated by the developer community.
Reporting problems
Problems (that covers errors, enhancement request, etc.) concerning the
&app; project are maintained
using the SourceForge.net platform. This is the sole location, where
problems have to be reported. The source for such a problem report can be
one of the developers or any other user of &app;.
Referencing problems
Once added to the database, the problem will be assigned a unique problem
number. This number must be mentioned whenever the problem is referenced
(e.g. in the subject of a mail to the developer mailing-list, a checkin
comment or an entry in the ChangeLog file). To allow searches for the number,
a specific format has to be used for these references.
The format is
#assigned-number, e.g. #481229.
Problem attributes
Besides the fixed problem number which is created when the report is filed,
each
problem has a couple of attributes that might change during the
life-cycle of the problem. They will be described in the following
chapters.
Reported By
As the problem number, this field is fix. It represents the SourceForge
username of the individual who filed the report.
Severity level
The SourceForge.net platform allows to assign a severity level to each
problem. It ranges from 1 to 10. The meaning in our project and the
consequences are defined as follows:
FIXME: A more detailed description of the prios needs to be given
Lowest priority
TBD!
TBD!
TBD!
Medium priority (default)
TBD!
TBD!
TBD!
TBD!
Highest priority
Area
TBD!
Assignee
This field represents the SourceForge.net username of the individual
working on the problem. Each developer should pick problems he feels
competent to work on. The possibility to assign another developer to a
problem should be used only to gather a comment from this developer. This
should be clearly marked as comment with the report.
The number of unassigned problem reports should be 0 most of the time to
give clear signal to the world that the developers are working on the
project!
Status
Each problem has a status. Right after filing a report, it will be assigned
the status 'open' automatically by the SourceForge.net platform. Whenever a
developer is working on the problem, he will have to modifiy the value of
this field to reflect the current status. The following values are
available and have the associated meaning:
Available problem status values
Status
Meaning
open
The problem is not yet fixed. A developer might be working on it.
closed
The problem has been closed. No further action is required.
deleted
???
pending
The problem has been modified solved and feedback from the original poster
is required. Pending entries will turn into closed entries after 14 days.
Resolution
The following values are available and have the associated meaning:
Available problem resolution values
Resolution
Meaning
Accepted
The problem report has been accepted by the developers. Nevertheless, it
has not yet been duplicated but from the initial report it could well
be a problem with &app;
Duplicated
The problem has been duplicated by one of the developers.
Fixed
The problem has been fixed. The code is available via CVS.
Invalid
The report is not valid. It's not a problem related to &app;.
Later
???
None
???
Out of date
The report is based on an older version of &app; and has been resolved
in the meantime in a newer release which is available for download or CVS.
Postponed
The problem has been acknowledged but will be postponed until later. The
developer changeing the state to Postponed should leave a comment with the
entry why it is postponed.
Rejected
The problem has been rejected by the development team. The developer
changing the state to Rejected should leave a comment with the entry
nameing the reasons for rejection.
Remind
???
Wont fix
???
Works for me
The problem cannot be duplicated but seems to be a valid problem. The
entry needs more investigation.